Compare · Supplements and vitamins
The best Shopify subscription app for a supplement store
Ranked by how many of the 10 features that matter most to a supplement store each app's own pages document: =1. Appstle Subscriptions + Appstle Bundles (5), =1. Loop (5), =1. Recharge (5), =1. Skio (5), =1. Supr (5), 6. Beez (2). We make Supr, which documents 5 of 10, level with Appstle Subscriptions + Appstle Bundles, Loop, Recharge, Skio. The right app is the one that documents the features your store needs, so check those rows.
We make Supr. The rule is the same for every app and every claim links to the app's own page.
Install on ShopifyThe features that decide it for a supplement store
Yes DocumentedPartly PartlyNo Their docs say noNot documented Not publicly documented2 apps Needs a second app
| Feature | Supr | Recharge | Appstle Subscriptions + Appstle Bundles | Skio | Loop | Beez |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bundles 2 features | ||||||
| Volume / quantity break on one product | Yes | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | |
| Bundle can be bought on subscription | Yes | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | |
| Retention 5 features | ||||||
| Cancellation flow with reason survey | Yes | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented | |
| Per-reason offers | Yes | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented | |
| Merchant chooses what happens when the last payment retry fails | Yes | Not documented | SubscriptionsNot documented, Appstle Subscriptions | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| A failed renewal is retried immediately when the customer updates payment | Yes | Not documented | SubscriptionsNot documented, Appstle Subscriptions | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Portal and cancellation screens show how much the subscriber has saved | Yes | Not documented | SubscriptionsNot documented, Appstle Subscriptions | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Operations, analytics, integrations 2 features | ||||||
| Klaviyo integration | Yes | Yes source | Yes source | Yes source | Not documented | |
| Renewals needing 3D Secure / SCA authentication are handled | Yes | Not documented | SubscriptionsNot documented, Appstle Subscriptions | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
| Subscriptions: offers and pricing 1 features | ||||||
| Interval changes automatically after N orders | Yes | Not documented | SubscriptionsNot documented, Appstle Subscriptions | Not documented | Not documented | Not documented |
Set it up in Supr: 1, 3 and 6 packs at 0, 10 and 20% off, each with its own delivery speed
A vitamin brand sells a 1, 3 and 6 pack on one product page, with a bigger discount for a bigger pack and a delivery frequency that matches how long the pack lasts.
- In Shopify, open Supr Bundle & Subscription App > Offers, click Create offer and choose Bundle + Subscription.
- Under Choose a bundle type, pick Quantity breaks (the app's name for a bigger discount on bigger packs).
- Add three options with Quantity 1, 3 and 6, and set Price to Percentage off at 0, 10 and 20.
- Add a subscription option for each delivery speed, and turn on Restrict to specific bundle options so each pack shows only its own frequency.
- Switch on the upcoming repeat order email so customers get a reminder before every charge.
How to offer a bigger discount when customers buy more · How to reduce subscription cancellations
Supr against each app, for a supplement store
Questions
Can each pack size have its own delivery frequency?
Yes. On each subscription option, turn on Restrict to specific bundle options and tick only its pack, so a 1 bottle pack can ship every 30 days and a 3 bottle pack every 90.
What happens when a subscriber's card fails?
Failed payments are retried on a schedule you set, customers get emails along the way, and you choose what happens after the last retry.
Can I remind subscribers before each charge?
Yes. Turn on the upcoming repeat order email. Its lead time is a store-wide setting.
How do you rank apps for a supplement store?
By how many of the 10 features that matter most to a supplement store each app's own public pages document. A feature counts only when the app's pages say it exists, and Not documented means the pages do not say.
Guides for a supplement store
- How does a supplement store offer auto-ship every 30, 60 or 90 days on Shopify?
- How does a supplement store give a bigger discount for bigger packs on Shopify?
- How does a pet food store handle failed subscription payments on Shopify?
- Which five Klaviyo flows should a subscription box brand build first?